What is a better newsletter sign-up rate worth?
Problem
- Almost every visitor leaves without leaving a way to reach them again, so the site has to win them back from search.
- A sign-up box nobody notices quietly costs the subscribers it never collected, every month.
Solution
- Work out your sign-up rate - new subscribers a month divided by visits a month from your WebCounter counter.
- Put it into the free calculator below and compare it with a better box, before you redesign anything.
Key points
- Doubling the sign-up rate doubles the list - the losses scale with it.
- At 1% of 10,000 visits a month the list is about 1,080 after a year in our example.
- At 2% it is about 2,150 after a year, and about 3,840 after two.
- A list that loses 2% a month levels off at 50 months of sign-ups - 5,000 at 1%, 10,000 at 2%.
- Every subscriber is a reader who comes back when you send - the most reliable returning visitor there is.
In how many newsletter subscribers you will have after a year we grew a list from a sign-up rate. In what a newsletter subscriber is worth we priced one name. This post asks which lever is worth pulling: what a better sign-up rate adds to the list, from the same traffic.
What moves the sign-up rate
People sign up when the offer is clear, worth having and in front of them at the right moment.
- Say what they will get and how often - "one email on Fridays with the week's new posts" beats "subscribe to our newsletter".
- Put the box where reading ends, at the bottom of a post, not only in a sidebar nobody looks at.
- Match the offer to the page - a reader of a pricing post wants price updates, not general news.
- In South Africa POPIA requires consent for marketing email, so a clear opt-in is the law, not just good manners.
Work out what your sign-up rate builds
Type your own numbers into the calculator below - your visits, your sign-up rate and the share of subscribers you lose - and it shows how the list grows.
Prefer a full page? Open the newsletter growth calculator on CalcSA. To price each subscriber, the newsletter subscriber value calculator goes deeper.
Worked example: 10,000 visits a month
A site gets 10,000 visits a month and loses an illustrative 2% of its subscribers each month. Three sign-up rates, counted over 24 months:
- 0.5% sign up (50 a month): about 540 subscribers after a year, about 960 after two.
- 1% sign up (100 a month): about 1,080 after a year, about 1,920 after two.
- 2% sign up (200 a month): about 2,150 after a year, about 3,840 after two.
- The list never stops growing, but it slows - at 2% lost a month it levels off near 50 months' worth of sign-ups.
Illustrative. The 10,000 visits, the 0.5%, 1% and 2% sign-up rates and the 2% lost a month are assumptions chosen to show the shape - no published benchmark was used. Your email tool shows your real sign-ups and losses.
Two years of list growth
Subscribers on the list each month from 10,000 visits a month, losing 2% of the list a month:
- 0.5% sign up
- 1% sign up
- 2% sign up
Show the numbers as a table
| Month | 0.5% sign up | 1% sign up | 2% sign up |
|---|---|---|---|
| 0 | 0 | 0 | 0 |
| 3 | 147 | 294 | 588 |
| 6 | 285 | 571 | 1,142 |
| 12 | 538 | 1,076 | 2,153 |
| 24 | 961 | 1,921 | 3,842 |
- Fix the sign-up rate before chasing more traffic - it compounds on every visit you already get.
- Test one change at a time - the wording, then the place, then the offer.
- Watch the losses too - a bigger box that brings people who leave at once builds nothing.
Reading your counter for this
Your WebCounter counter shows visits by page, so you can work out the sign-up rate for the whole site and for the pages that matter. No counter yet? Get your free WebCounter counter - it takes a minute and costs nothing.
- Sign-up rate: new subscribers a month from your email tool, divided by visits a month from your counter.
- Best pages: the posts with the most visits are where a better box adds the most names.
- Returning visitors: once the list grows, returners should rise on the days you send.
- Count bots out - bot visits make your sign-up rate look lower than it is.
Sources
- Protection of Personal Information Act 4 of 2013, section 69 - consent for direct marketing by electronic communication - summarised, not legal advice.
- The 10,000 visits, the 0.5%, 1% and 2% sign-up rates and the 2% lost a month are our illustrative assumptions - no published benchmark for sign-up rates was used.
- Calculator: CalcSA, Newsletter growth.
Estimates only. Your sign-up rate depends on your readers and your offer; your email tool and your own counter are the test.
Count your page views - free
WebCounter gives your site a free counter and a 30-day report of page views and real visitors, with bots filtered out. No cookies on your visitors.
Get your free counter